Skip to content
Insights · The product system

A formula is not a product

A formula becomes a product only when customer, experience, economics, claims, packaging, manufacturing and distribution work together.

Trent Jackson · Draft, not yet published · 5 min

A formula is a list: what goes in each serving, and how much. It answers one question. A product has to answer seven more: who takes it, what it is like to take, what it earns, what it can say, what it comes in, how it gets made the same way every time, and where it sells.

A formula becomes a product only when those answers agree with each other. That is why a strong formula can still fail as a product, and why a problem that looks like a formula problem is often somewhere else.

Seven things that have to agree

Customer. One person who takes it, at a particular moment, for a reason. "Everyone who trains" is not a customer. A product made for a specific person can make real choices about dose, flavor and serving size. The useful version of this answer also says why they come back for more. A supplement taken once is a sample, not a product.

Experience. What it is like to take every day: the taste, the texture, how it mixes, how it sits. Experience is part of the product, not decoration on it. It is also where descriptions fail. People turn down a change when it is described to them and accept the same change once they taste it. So flavor is decided by tasting, before anything is locked.

Economics. What it sells for, what it costs to make, and what is left after the channel and the running of the business take their share. Premium ingredients at a dose that leaves no margin make a good formula and a bad product. (How do you know whether the product economics work? takes this apart.)

Claims. What the label and the marketing can say. The promise has to be one the product can support and one the person buying it cares about. A claim written after the formula is fixed is a claim you inherit, not one you chose.

Packaging. The format and the pack: a tub, a bag, stick packs, sachets, capsules, a ready-to-drink. Format changes the experience, the cost of each serving, and where it can sell. A stick pack goes in a gym bag. A tub stays on the counter. They are different products even with the same formula inside.

Manufacturing. Whether it can be made the same way every run, in the format you chose, at the cost the economics assumed. This is where the other answers become a commitment. A first run starts at 1,000 units per product, and every reorder has to come out like the last one.

Distribution. Where it sells, and what it has to beat there. A clinic, a coach's program, a brand's own site and a marketplace each bring different prices, different competitors and different needs from the pack. The answer reaches back into price, pack and claims.

Seven parts, each with its own specialist, and one product that needs them to agree. Who keeps them agreeing is its own question: The owner should not have to become the integration layer.

Where formulas usually stop

A formula usually starts with someone who knows what should be in it: a practitioner with a protocol, a coach with a stack, a founder with an ingredient they believe in. The formula gets made first, and the rest gets decided around it. The flavor is fixed to suit the ingredients. The price is set to cover the cost. The claim is written to describe what is inside. The pack is whatever the formula fits.

Each of those decisions is reasonable on its own. Together they produce a product built from the inside out. It describes its ingredients instead of doing something for a person, and it is hard to sell for exactly that reason.

The other order works better. Decide who it is for, where it sells, what it sells for, what it can cost to make and what it has to beat. Then write the formula to fit those answers. The formula is still the heart of the product, but it is written to the answers instead of being asked to supply them. (Why product definition should come before formulation makes the case for that order.)

What this is not

This is not an argument that every product needs rebuilding, or that every formula needs a strategy project before anyone mixes a sample.

If you already sell a product and people reorder it, most of the seven already agree. Sales have proven your customer, your price, your pack and your channel. The work there is keeping them in agreement when one part moves: a manufacturer that slips, a cost that climbs, a new flavor, a new format. Changing one part should not quietly break the others.

And if you already know who takes it, where it sells and what it has to beat, you do not need anyone to tell you. You need the formula written to those answers.

How to tell which one you have

Answer these five in a sentence each, without using the word "everyone":

  1. Who takes it, and when?
  2. Where does it sell?
  3. What does it sell for?
  4. What can it cost to make?
  5. What does it have to beat?

All five answered: you have the start of a product, and the formula can be written to it. Some answered: the gaps are the work. None answered: you have a formula or an idea, and the next step is deciding what to make, not making it.

The remaining parts get settled while the product is built, by approval: the formula, the flavor after tasting rounds, the pack, and the first run. Five answers before, four approvals during. That is the system in one line.

If you already sell a product, ask a different question: when it reorders, does it come back the same, on time, at a cost that still works? If it does, the system is holding. If it doesn't, one part has come loose. When should you change supplement manufacturers? is about finding which one.

Where this sits

This is the premise. Every other article in the library rests on it.

Next: see how the work runs, from strategy to reorder, and the two ways in. How it works →

UpstreamThis is the premise. Every other article in the library rests on it.
DownstreamHow it works
RelatedNearest questions
Pureformance Nutrition / InsightsAll current works on one page. No page two.