Skip to content
Insights · Existing products and manufacturing

When should you change supplement manufacturers?

A switch is justified by fit, reliability, capability, economics or continuity, not change for its own sake.

Trent Jackson · Draft, not yet published · 5 min

Change manufacturers when the relationship can no longer give your product what it needs: the right fit, reliable runs, the capability for what comes next, economics that still work, and continuity you can count on. Not because a competitor sent a lower number, and not because moving feels like progress.

A switch has a real cost. The product has to come back the same, which takes matching and tasting. The move has to be timed so you don't run out. So a switch should fix something specific, and you should be able to name it.

Here are the five things worth naming, plus the one that disguises itself.

Fit

Fit is whether you are the kind of account your manufacturer is built for. Volumes move. A brand that was a large customer at a small facility can become too big for its lines. A brand that was small at a large facility can stay too small to be a priority.

Fit runs both ways. Manufacturers do their best work for accounts that are easy to run: clean specifications, decisions made, one person to call. Part of a good fit is on your side of the table.

The question: when you call, are you an account they are built to serve?

Reliability

Reliability is the one you feel first. Runs that ship late. Answers that take a week. A run that comes back different from the last one: clumping, a flavor that drifted, a texture that changed.

One late run is an event. A pattern is a reliability problem, and it compounds, because every late run pushes your reorder, your launch and your cash.

The question: could you plan a launch around their next date?

Capability

Capability is whether they can make what comes next, not only what you make now. A brand that wants to add capsules or a ready-to-drink version, or start a new line, can find that its manufacturer runs one kind of product well and nothing else.

This one matters before it hurts. You find out you have outgrown a manufacturer's capability when the next product has nowhere to go.

The question: can they make the product you want to sell next year?

Economics

Economics is not the lowest price. It is whether the whole cost of the relationship still works for your margins: the price per unit, and also the minimums, the payment terms, the reruns, and the hours you spend chasing.

Prices that keep climbing are a sign worth reading closely. If the increases track what the materials cost, that is the market. If you cannot trace them to anything, that is the relationship.

The question: can you explain your last price change? What to evaluate before accepting a manufacturing quote covers the terms that sit around the number.

Continuity

Continuity is whether your product survives a change you don't control: your contact leaves, the company changes hands, an ingredient gets hard to source.

The quiet risk is when one person's inbox is the only full record of your product. Specifications, approved samples, the last formula change: if those live only with your manufacturer's contact, they can leave with that person.

The question: if your contact left tomorrow, would you still have everything you need to make your product somewhere else?

Reorder windows

Missed reorder windows look like a manufacturer problem. Sometimes they are. Often they are a chain: the lead time, your forecast, the approvals, the cash for the deposit, the packaging, and the messages in between. Any one link can make you run out, and a stockout rarely has one cause.

So before a stockout becomes a reason to switch, find the link that failed. If it was their side, a slow confirmation or a run that slipped, it is a reliability sign. If it was your forecast or your packaging arriving late, a new manufacturer inherits the same problem.

The question: the last time you ran out, which link broke?

What this is not

A lower quote on its own is not a reason to move. A per-unit price is one term among several, and a quote on a product nobody has matched yet is a quote on a different product.

A problem on your side is not a reason to move either. Late packaging, a forecast made too late, approvals that sit for a week: those travel with you.

And looking is not the same as leaving. Sometimes the honest result of comparing is to stay, or to fix one thing and stay. That is a good outcome. You know more than you did, and you made the call yourself.

How to tell which one you have

Six questions, one per sign. Answer them about the last twelve months:

  1. Did a run arrive late enough to cost you sales?
  2. Did a run come back different from the one before it?
  3. Is there a product you want to make that they can't?
  4. Has your price moved in a way you can't trace?
  5. If your contact left, would your product's details leave too?
  6. Did you run out of stock, and was the broken link on their side?

A yes on their side is a reason to look. A yes on your side is a reason to fix your side first. No yeses: stay, and keep your records current.

The safest way to look is to compare before you move anything. That is what Switch is. You send us your product. We match it and price it. You taste yours and ours side by side, and you switch only if ours is better. It is free to the brand, and the match report is yours either way.

Where this sits

Upstream: A formula is not a product. Changing manufacturers changes one of the seven parts. The other six should still agree when it lands.

Sideways:

Next: see what better looks like before you move anything. How Switch works →

RelatedNearest questions
Pureformance Nutrition / InsightsAll current works on one page. No page two.