Skip to content
Insights · Building a product line

Why product definition should come before formulation

An unresolved customer, promise, economics or route to market should not be hardened into a formula and inventory.

Trent Jackson · Draft, not yet published · 4 min

Starting with the formula feels like progress. It's the part you can taste, and it's usually the part the founder cares about most. But a formula turns decisions into ingredients, and a first run turns ingredients into inventory. Every step makes an unanswered question more expensive to answer.

So answer the questions while they're still cheap. Decide who it's for, what it promises, what it has to cost and where it sells. Then write the formula.

Why the order matters: things harden

The same decision costs different amounts depending on when you make it.

On paper, changing who the product is for costs a conversation. In the lab, it costs sample rounds, because the dose, the flavor and the format were chosen for someone else. After a first run of 1,000 units per product, it costs the run.

That's the whole argument. Definition isn't a slower way to start. It's the stage where changing your mind is free.

The order

Four questions, in order, each with a gate. They're the same questions the application asks, grouped by what they decide.

1. Customer: who takes it, and when?

One person, one moment, one reason. A product for "people who care about their health" can't make choices. A product for a patient on a specific protocol, or an athlete before a morning session, can choose its dose, its flavor and its serving size.

Gate: you can describe the person who reorders it, and why they reorder.

2. Promise: what does it do for them?

The promise is what the product does for that person, in words they'd use. It is not the ingredient list and not the science behind it. People buy what a product does for them.

The promise also sets what the label has to support. Some promises are ones a supplement can make; some aren't. Settling the promise before the formula means the formula is built to support a claim you chose, instead of the claim being written around whatever the formula turned out to be.

Gate: you can say what it does in one sentence, and the claims to steer clear of are named.

3. Economics: what does it sell for, and what can it cost to make?

The price it sells for, minus what the channel and the business take, sets what the product can cost to make. That number decides what the formula can include: which ingredients, at what dose, in what format.

Formulate first and the cost becomes whatever the formula costs. Then the price has to stretch to cover it, or the margin disappears.

Gate: you know the price and the cost the product has to be made for. (How do you know whether the product economics work? covers what sits between them.)

4. Route to market: where does it sell, and what does it have to beat?

The route shapes the product. Each place it could sell sets its own price, its own pack and its own competition, so the formula can't be finished until you know which one you're building for.

What it has to beat is part of this answer. If you don't know what your customer buys now, you don't know what the formula has to do better.

Gate: you know where it sells, and you've named what it has to beat.

Then: the formula

Now the formula has a brief. It's written for a person, to keep a promise, at a cost, for a channel, against a competitor. Tasting rounds refine a product that already knows what it's for. That's when formulating gets fast. And once the formula, the flavor and the pack are approved, When is a supplement product ready for manufacturing? is the last check before the first run.

The usual failure

The formula comes first, because someone knows exactly what should be in it. It's a good formula. Then the price comes out higher than the channel will pay. The claim the founder wanted isn't one the label can carry. The format that suited the ingredients isn't the one the customers want. Each problem gets patched, and the product that reaches the shelf is a compromise of patches.

Nothing in that story is a bad decision. It's the right decisions in the wrong order.

If you already know

Definition is a step, not a toll. If you can already answer the four questions, you don't need anyone to walk you through them again. You need the formula written to your answers.

Our application asks five things: who takes it and when, where it sells, what it sells for, what it can cost to make, and what it has to beat. Answer them and we skip Define and quote the development from the call. Answer some, and the gaps get filled inside the quote. Answer none, and Define is where we start: a sit-down with a product expert, then a one-page plan with a verdict to proceed, reshape or pause. Define decides what to make. The build makes it.

Where this sits

Upstream: A formula is not a product. This is the order that article argues for.

Sideways:

Next: answer the five questions. Blank answers are fine; they tell us where to start. Apply →

RelatedNearest questions
Pureformance Nutrition / InsightsAll current works on one page. No page two.