Skip to content
Insights · Building a product line

Should you build your own supplement product line?

The opportunity depends on customer need, right to win, distribution, economics, capital and operating ownership.

Trent Jackson · Draft, not yet published · 4 min

Build one when six things line up: a recurring need, a reason people would buy it from you, a way to reach them that you already have, economics that leave money after the channel, the capital to get through a first run, and someone to run it after launch.

An audience is one of those six, not all of them. Attention is not demand. Followers, patients, clients and credentials are a route to people. Whether those people will buy a product, and keep buying it, is a separate question.

Customer need: will they take it again next month?

Start with the need, and check that it recurs. A supplement that is taken every day, or on a protocol, gets reordered. A product people try once is a launch spike followed by a quiet shelf.

"My audience already asks what I take" is a good sign. It means the need exists and your opinion matters to them. The test is narrower: would they buy your version, at your price, and reorder it without you reminding them?

The question: what does it do for them, and why would they need it again?

Right to win: why from you?

Your right to win is the reason someone picks your product over the one they buy now. For a doctor, it might be a protocol their patients already follow. For a coach, it might be the training their clients already do. That trust is specific. It covers what you're known for, and it doesn't stretch far beyond it. A sleep doctor's name carries weight on a sleep product. On a pre-workout, less so.

Right to win also means knowing what you have to beat. There is almost always something already on the shelf.

The question: what does it have to beat, and why would your people switch?

Distribution: can you reach them again and again?

An audience is distribution only if you can reach it repeatedly, on terms you control. Patients you see every month, clients in a program, an email list that reads what you send: those are routes. A viral moment is not.

Where it sells also shapes the product: its price, its pack and its claims. Choose the route before the formula, not after.

The question: where does it sell, and how often do you reach the people who would buy it?

Economics: what is left after the channel?

Retail price minus the cost to make it is not what you keep. The channel takes a share, shipping and fulfillment take a share, and running the business takes a share. What is left has to pay back everything spent before the first sale.

The question: at your price, after everything, is there a business? How do you know whether the product economics work? walks through the costs.

Capital: can you get through the first run?

A product line costs money before it makes any. Development, samples, packaging, design, and the first run itself, which starts at 1,000 units per product. That inventory is paid for before it sells.

Capital doesn't prove demand, but a lack of it can sink a good product. The worst version is a product that sells, runs out, and can't be reordered because the cash is still sitting in the first run.

The question: could you pay for the first run and the months it takes to sell?

Operating ownership: who runs it after launch?

Someone has to run the product once it exists: reorders, forecasting, new flavors, label updates, customer questions, fulfillment. Some of that can be handed off. None of it disappears.

If you're a practitioner or a creator, your time is already spoken for. That is a reason to hand the product side to a team, not a reason to skip the question.

The question: who places the reorder, and who answers when a customer writes?

What this is not

This is not a case for everyone with an audience to make a product.

If you'd sell fewer than about 1,000 units a year, a product of your own usually isn't worth it yet. A good existing product, recommended well, may serve your people better than a weak one with your name on it.

If what you want is the endorsement, not the business, that is a different deal. A product line is a business with inventory, reorders and customers who expect it in stock.

And if the product's best feature is the innovation behind it rather than what it does for the person taking it, slow down. The innovation is how it works. The customer is buying what it does.

How to tell which one you have

Answer the six questions above, one sentence each. Then check the line under them: would you sell at least about 1,000 units a year?

  • All six answered, and over the line: you have an opportunity. The next step is building it well.
  • Some answered: you have a promising idea with gaps. The gaps are the work, and they cost less to close on paper than in inventory.
  • Under the line, or most unanswered: not yet. That is a real answer.

Where this sits

Upstream: A formula is not a product. An audience settles part of one of the seven parts. The other six still have to agree.

Sideways:

Next: see how a product goes from an idea to a first run, with one team behind it. How Launch works →

RelatedNearest questions
Pureformance Nutrition / InsightsAll current works on one page. No page two.